![]() |
| Toronto Catholic Trustees |
The proposal to ban Gay/Straight Alliances in Catholic
schools was rejected last night at the Toronto Catholic District School Board meeting by a vote of 7 to 4. It was another very sad day for Catholic education in the
province of Ontario. There were in total twenty individuals and groups making
presentations about the issue. Most of the speakers argued in favor of banning
GSAs in separate schools. Thirteen presenters argued for the motion and
seven against it. In the end, here's how the trustees voted:
Trustees voting to ban GSAs
Partizia Bottoni
John Del Grande
Garry Tanuan
Angela Kennedy
Trustees voting for GSAs
Peter Jakovcic
Ann Andrachuck
Sal Piccininni
Maria Rizzo
Jo-Ann Davis
Barbara Poplawski
Frank D'Amico (Absent)
Nancy Crawford
Nancy Crawford
There were a number of speakers and trustees who argued that Ontario law now permits these student clubs and the Board needs to respect
the law. However, Trustee Garry Tanuan pointed out that his motion was an attempt to defend
denominational rights and religious freedom. The Equity and Inclusive Education Strategy and Bill 13 "legally" force GSAs on Catholic schools. Tanuan argued that
Catholic education is protected by the Canadian constitution and as a result Catholics
have a right to implement school policies consistent with Catholic teaching. He was supported by Trustees Bottoni, Kennedy and Del Grande.
What was evident last night is that some trustees
either don't know Catholic teaching or they have no interest in defending it.
Trustee Piccininni said that those who oppose GSAs are "on the wrong side of
history." It's outdated not to have GSAs. He went on to argue that the
Board must be progressive and in dealing with these issues it "cannot wrap
itself in the Bible." Trustee Rizzo said that there are "different
kinds of Catholics" and in the Church "there's room for you and for
me." For her, Jesus "was inclusive" and so she could not support
the ban on GSAs.
In the end when the vote was taken, the the motion was voted down. The
seven trustees that made this possible were essentially supporting what the
Ontario Minister of Education has said about the issue, “It is our
responsibility to ensure all students feel safe and welcomed at school. I know
that Catholic values of tolerance and love make them natural allies in the
fight against bullying. I hope the Board will continue to foster an accepting
environment for all students.” In short, no school board can be exempted from
having GSAs. Parents should ask: Where's the "inclusion and
equitable" part in the policy and legislation if it rejects Chriatian teaching? if Catholic principals, students and teachers refuse to follow this law because of their religious beliefs will they now be committing a "crime"?
If the motion was against Ontario law as some
trustees argued, then it's "illegal" to fully live the Catholic faith in Catholic
schools. In June 2012, the Ontario government passed Bill 13, known as the
Accepting Schools Act, which "legally" allows students to set up GSAs
if they want them in both Catholic and public schools. The anti-bullying
legislation forces all schools to address the issue by allowing GSAs.
The Catholic trustees could have mounted a legal
challenge against Bill 13 using Canada’s constitution. But rather than make the
government accountable for underminig Catholic doctrine they have chosen to appease them
and follow the legislation. Last night's vote was just another example of this. If Catholic leaders thought that Catholic schools could use the
"Respecting Difference" document put out by the Ontario Catholic
Trustees' Association to deal with bullying, last night's vote made it clear
that they cannot do so. The vote was essentially a rejection of any attempt to
implement a Catholic approach to bullying, to human sexuality and the family.
Given this outcome, Catholic parents need to ask themselves this question: do we really want Catholic schools to have a future in Ontario? If the answer is yes, then last night's vote shows just how much work needs to be done to defend Catholic education. It's a matter of living the faith and making the necessary sacrifices to pass it on to our children. The educational system in Ontario, including the Catholic schools, will not do this on their own. Trustees made it clear last night. Parents have the responsibility and the need to reclaim Catholic education for the sake of their children's well being and their souls.
Given this outcome, Catholic parents need to ask themselves this question: do we really want Catholic schools to have a future in Ontario? If the answer is yes, then last night's vote shows just how much work needs to be done to defend Catholic education. It's a matter of living the faith and making the necessary sacrifices to pass it on to our children. The educational system in Ontario, including the Catholic schools, will not do this on their own. Trustees made it clear last night. Parents have the responsibility and the need to reclaim Catholic education for the sake of their children's well being and their souls.








